Books
on Sargent
New

By Barbara
Dayer Gallati -- in connection with the Exhibition: Great Expectations
John
Singer Sargent: Portraits of the 1890s (Complete Paintings:
Volume
II) and John
Singer Sargent The Late Portraits: Complete Paintings (Volume
III)
John
Singer Sargent: Portraits of the 1890s (Complete Paintings: Volume
II) |
John
Singer Sargent The Late Portraits: Complete Paintings (Volume III) |
Essentially what
everyone was waiting
for: the third portrait book is out along with the second which
completes
the trilogy of portrait books by Elaine Kilmurray and Richard Ormond
"Sargent
and Italy"
by Bruce Robertson,
editor with
essays by Richard Ormond, Jane Dini, Ilene Susan Fort, Stephanie L.
Herdrich,
R.W.B. Lewis.
This
extravagantly illustrated catalogue--published
in association with a major
transatlantic exhibition--evokes the romantic fascination with
Italy
that glimmers in the work of John Singer Sargent.
Includes 85 color
and 50 black-and-white
images. It adds a new dimension to our appreciation of Sargent's art
and
will delight anyone who loves Italy, as Sargent so passionately
did.
Editorial Picks
In order to help
the reader distinguish
between the mountain of books available, I have written a few brief
reviews
on some of the major books. Since you probably don't know my tastes,
I've
tried to give both what I felt was good and weak about each book. Any
of
these in my opinion are worth your money so understand in describing
the
weaknesses, I'm being very picky.
There are three
categories of books
you can buy.
- The
Biography
- The
Table-Top Survey
Book
- The Niche Book
1) The Biography.
The basic
narrative story about his life. Like most biographies, these are mostly
narrative text with a few black and white photographs.
Probably
one of the best books in this category is "John
Singer Sargent : His Portrait" by Stanley Olson. It's a
great
read and is the product of reportedly six years of research (and it
shows).
The downside, of course, is that it has few pictures and assumes you
know
his body of work -- (that you know what the paintings look like). My
site
helps a great deal as a companion and pretty much nullifies any
negative
downside. 309 pages with 45 black-and-white images which include a mix
of photographs of John and some of his friends and people he
painted.
2) Table-Top Survey
Books
-- These books are geared to the enjoyment of the images of Sargent's
paintings
in a pleasing large book format. Generally they give only a brief
survey
of some of his periods. Of these its hard to pick the best, since so
many
bring different things to the table. Two stand out, in my mind, as the
better ones.
One
of the best attempts at giving you a look at his life AND his work is "John
Singer Sargent" by Carter Ratcliff. This is an outstanding book
by Ratcliff and well written. No other book has been able to mesh both
the story of his life with critical analysis of his work as well as
Ratcliff
has done. None. On the downside, although the color images are good,
they
aren't the best of the Table-Top Survey books probably due to the fact
that it first went to print in the early '80s. (printing quality have
improved
a lot since then). Reprint additions seem to still have this somewhat
inferior
image plate setup. The selection of paintings is wonderfully
picked
and balanced and I highly recommend it. 256 pages. Over 300
illustrations,
113 in color, over 187 in black-and-white (many of the black-and-white
deal with the murals).
A solidly scholared piece of work by
Elaine Kilmurray and Richard
Ormond
called "Sargent".
Covers the breath of his work and gives highlights of some of the
significant
paintings. You can't help but come away with a good understanding of
Sargent
after reading this book. The book is very good. I just happen to prefer
the Ratcliff. In some ways this is an outline for a much larger
project
that both editors are working on -- an intensive and comprehensive
multi-volume
work on each period. Wonderfully researched and the pictures (after all
that's really what most people are after) are very very good.285 pages,
with 171 color images and 85 black-and-white.
3) Niche Books
-- these are
books that deal with a particular segment of Sargent's life or work.
There
are so many of these that its very difficult to break out. But here are
some of the highly worthy:
At
the top of the heap is Kilmurray and Ormond's first volume "John
Singer Sargent : The Early Portraits (The Complete Paintings , Vol 1)"
. Where their survey book falls a little short, this one comes storming
through both in the writing and the images. It really doesn't get any
better
then this. The highest quality of everything, The book catalogs his
portraits
from the years 1874 to 1887. This has outstanding color plate images.
There
is no down side to this book . . . unless . . . . well, you just don't
want it to end. 256 pages, 180 color and 80 b&w images -- all
portraits.
"Strapless:
The Rise of John Singer Sargent and the Fall of Madame X" by
Deborah
Davis
About a month
ago, I guess, I was
privileged enough to have received an advance copy of "Strapless" from
Deborah Davis. Having a million things on my desk it took me a few days
before I finally got around to picking it up, but I got to tell you,
once
I picked it up, I never wanted to put it down.
For over a
hundred years, THE
REAL STORY of Madame X has alluded every single scholar of John
Singer Sargent. From out of nowhere, Deborah Davis has managed to
nab the most important untold story in Sargent's life. It is a
astonishing
achievement for an author -- it is a phenomenal book, it's an
easy
read -- it's a MUST for any fan of John Singer Sargent --
Natasha
Wallace
Travel Paintings
There are two really
great books
on Sargent's travel paintings which have a good selection of
watercolors.
There are even others but these are my top picks:
"Sargent
Abroad : Figures and Landscapes" by Warren Adelson, Donna
Seldin
Janis, Elaine Kilmurray, Elizabeth Oustinoff, Richard Ormond. These are
some of the people that sit on the Catalogue Raisonne project and are
about
as expert as one can get. Outlines very well his travels throughout
Europe
and the quality of the images are every good. It's hard to put a
downside
to this, re-creating watercolors and oils in photographic images which
are then printed in books is a tricky endeavor. The hard-core purist
will
never be satisfied with anything but the original but this book does
very
well at coming close. Some people felt the watercolors were washed out
just a little. Another downside is the cost which puts it out of reach
to some. 256 pages, 233 illustrations: of which 93 color oils; 104
color
watercolors; 33 photographs; 3 black&white images.
"John
Singer Sargent : The Sensualist" is a wonderful book at a much
more approachable price. Though understand its a smaller book at 67
color
plates. It was written by Trevor Fairbrother who was the curator
of the Seattle Art Museum show which ended in March of, 2001. The book
was written to coincide with that show.
The thing I like
about all of Trevor's
books is that guy simply loves the art of John Singer Sargent and it
shows
in quality and size of the pictures of the paintings. In many cases
they
are near full page. The first part of the book is geared more to an
overview
of his earlier work and done mostly in black and white (highlighting
some
of his major paintings). So in a way it tries to be somewhat of a
survey
book.
The brilliance of
Trevor's book is
that it tries to bring out previously unpublished travel paintings
which
were not in "Sargent Abroad" or other books. The rear of
the
book is exclusively devoted to an album of Sargent's male figure
studies from the Harvard collection, printed on cream colored stock
(maybe
about a fifth or sixth of the book is devoted to the male nudes). The
quality
of the images are very good better, in fact than "Sargent
Abroad" (which is good) but there is less of them. It is hard to
put
a down side to these niche books. Trevor, in writing this, is advancing
a thesis as any good writer should. The selection of paintings is
geared
towards supporting his thesis so isn't necessarily a balanced
presentation
-- nor should it be for this excellent niche book. In fact, if money is
not an option, BOTH books are a must in anyone's collection on
Sargent. 226
pages with 67
color plates plus
the male nudes. [1]
Male Nudes
"John
Singer Sargent : The Male Nudes" by John Esten
might
be another you would want. The power of Sargent's art is what draws
most
people here. Published before Fairbrother's book, there isn't a lot of
overlap between the two, thanks to Trevor, so those interested in
Trevor's
book will want to have both. 79 pages with 15 color plates, and 34
black-and-white
drawings. [2]
For more books see Current
Available Books |